Crossing the Line

January 2026 feels like a turning point. Yes, we’ve had nearly a year of the Trump nightmare of an administration. In retrospect, however, 2025 seems like a gathering of momentum—like a pole-vaulter sprinting down the runway to take-off point. January was the vault into a previously un-American reality.

Is that new reality America as an authoritarian nation? There’s a technical, academic way of addressing this. Then there’s a common sense answer. Crossing the Line takes the second approach. My conclusion: we are no longer the nation we were for 250 years. We are an authoritarian country.

Not permanetly, perhaps. The fight is not over. Far from it. The United States has crossed a Rubicon, but not the point of no return. Minnesota is showing how to resist and reverse the Trump Administration’s power grab. As are the people standing up for their neighbors throughout the country, the lawyers and judges holding the line, and the journalists reporting the truth. Every time we attend a rally we’re pushing against Trump’s momentum. Every sign held up in protest matters. I remain optimistic we can prevail.

But what about that technical, academic way of addressing this? For that I turned to AI because nothing says unreliable, hallucinating, BS technical academia like artificial intelligence. The AIs I used were ChatGPT 5.1, Claude Sonnet 4.5, Grok (Elon Musk’s AI toy), and Lumo Plus (from the company that brings you ProtonMail).

First I asked them, “In 30 words or less, in bullet point fashion, list the elements that make for a fascist nation. Then use another 30 words or less to create a similar list for an authoritarian nation.” (Asking for a 30-word limit is crucial unless you’re willing to wade through War and Peace-length answers). Lumo’s response was typical:

Fascist:

• Authoritarian leadership

• Suppression of dissent

• Ultra‑nationalism

• State control of media

• Militarism

• Corporatist economy

Authoritarian:

• Authoritarian leadership

• Suppression of dissent

• Centralized power without democratic checks

• Limited political pluralism

• Controlled judiciary

• Restricted civil liberties (speech, assembly)

I then asked them “whether US has crossed the line into fascism, authoritarianism, or both?”

Here’s what each said:

ChatGPT 5.1: “I’d say we are in an advanced slide toward authoritarianism, not yet fully across the line.”

Lumo Plus: (Proton) “Based on the available evidence, the United States has moved beyond a democratic baseline and is now functioning as an authoritarian regime.”

Grok AI: (Musk) “The US has crossed into authoritarianism with emerging fascist traits like militarism and extreme nationalism. We are no longer just approaching.” (Yes, even the AI that Musk trains to be anti-woke, the AI that once proudly proclaimed it was the “Mecha Hitler” says we’re an authoritarian nation. Think about that).

Claude Sonnet 4.5: The US has crossed into authoritarian governance while retaining contested democratic mechanisms. Whether this becomes consolidated fascism depends on November's elections and whether courts/Congress continue effective resistance. Currently: authoritarian system with eroding but still-functioning democratic constraints. (Emphasis is Claude’s).

I don’t know which is more troubling: that common sense and artificial intelligence agree or that 3-out-of-4 of them conclude the United States is now an authoritarian nation. And the fourth says we’re only partially across that line.

But hey, on a lighter note, I got to go heavily into the humor of characters recognizing they’re in a comic strip. I always enjoy that.

sketchier